A really fascinating book on the role of make-believe violence with a really nuanced discussion of media violence. While it's focusing almost entirely on children it was really fascinating and a lot of stuff I didn't know here. It's also interesting to note that the author isn't really a progressive. As you read it you come to see the author as probably a pretty conservative person, at best maybe a centrist - several cases comes up where he really show he doesn't like certain media products - but one who was able to listen to the people in question - why do you partake in this product, and really follow that inquiry and come to conclusions that it isn't the evil that it's made out to be. Really fascinating. ( )

Started out interesting but felt it was saying the same things over and over again. Moved beyond what I had expected the book to be.

#38, 2004

A friend told me about this book, and I'm really glad she did. This was an interesting book offering an alternate view of the effects of entertainment violence on children. Rather than putting forward the mainstream opinion that TV and movie violence, "shooter" video games, and children playing with guns and army men is harmful to both the children and potentially to society, Jones suggests that allowing children to experience these things can actually be a healthy and empowering; that allowing children to indulge in fantasy violence helps them to learn to deal with the real violence they see and experience in the world, and can give them a safe outlet for their rage and feelings of inadequacy while they're growing and developing. Rather than trying to summarize his take on the scientific research, I'll just say that much of what he said really resonated for me, particularly when I think back to the ways that I myself used fantasy and entertainment in my own youth - and I didn't grow up to be a serial killer, now, did I? ::grin:: It's also made me think twice about some of my own parenting decisions, and to understand that just because my son likes to pretend he's Jafar (rather than Aladdin), he's not already on the path to being a serial killer, either. I found his argument to be very reassuring on the whole - the media has done a great job of convincing us that children today are more violent than in past generations, but crime statistics show that that this is just not true. I'd recommend this book to anyone who has concerns about children and violence. ( )

A comforting read for parents struggling with their childrens interest in "violent" type play and games. Debunks some of the myths surrounding vionce in our culture today. We get the impression that vionecamong youth has gone up in reality it has gone down and adult vilent has gone up. Still youth violence is twice as likley to be aired on the news than adult violence. ( )