I was not a fan of Judith McNaught's novel, "Remember When". The plot literally dragged on with no end in sight. So much of the thoughts were repeated throughout the novel, that I found myself skipping pages in hope of finding where the novel finally took off. It never did. A quarter of the way through, I finally skipped to the last chapter, to the predictable conclusion. Ms. McNaught seems to have quite the fan base. Since this is the first novel of hers that I have read, I will give another of her novels a chance. ( )

Good but not one of this author's greatest. I liked the extended scenes of the hero and heroine when they were young. Forward 17 years and the emotional level wasn't as intense as it could have been. Still I appreciated that the heroine stood by the hero instead of having one of those forced breakups that authors sometimes throw in to add tension. I did wish that the situation with the wife of his enemy had been explained a bit better Had he actually slept with the other guy's wife at some point? I think not from the way his character was written but there was one line that implied he had but I think it may just have been that she'd tried to seduce him before and failed. And then at the end I wanted to know what she ended up telling her husband when her daughter fessed up. Oh well minor details. ( )

This was pretty close to the first romance novel I ever read, and the story stayed with me. Cole and Diana are something special to me and always will be. ( )

I love this book. Although I think they could of built up a.liytle more anticipation to their relationship as hubby and wife. Also the ending seemed really rushed. I love that diana trusted him but a fewmore obstacles wouldnt have hurt. Otherwise love love love this book ( )

As big a fan as I used to be of Judith McNaught's work, this book always left me cold. In general, McNaught's contemporary romances are less appealing than her historicals, but "Remember When" is particularly bland and forgettable. ( )