Not really sure who the intended audience of this title was—maybe high school students?

The book tries to tell the story of both Harlow and his work, and it didn't really work for me, since Harlow's life wasn't sufficiently dramatic. Still, an interesting moment in the history of science.

Dylan Meconis does a fine job with the art, but her skill has definitely improved since this title. ( )

Wire Mothers: Harry Harlow and the Science of Love by Jim Ottaviani is a graphic novel account of the psychology research done on the parent / child relationship and child self-esteem and mental health. At the forefront of this research was Harry Harlow who used rhesus monkeys (mothers and babies) to show the importance of physical contact to express love between parent and child.

The popular idea in the early to mid 20th century was that children needed to learn how to tough it out on their own. Parents were advised to avoid excessive physical contact with their children and to let babies cry it out. Babies and toddlers were kept in playpens and infants were primarily bottle fed. And a few years later, therapists reaped the benefits.

By the time I was born the pendulum was swinging more towards baby wearing, natural childbirth, and breast feeding, though those bits of advice hadn't yet become completely mainstream as they were by the time I had my children at the start of the 21st century.

We can see the start of this swing in the second season episode of Bewitched, "And Then There Were Three" where Tabitha is born. Although Samantha (at least while in the hospital) is willing to play by the parenting rules that the nurse, and husband Darrin, believe in. But Endora, her mother, is far too Bohemian, to believe such idiotic advice. She sets forth a series of misunderstandings by doing a very loving thing: picking up her crying grand-daughter from the nursery and taking her back to Samantha. Nowadays, infants stay with their mothers for most, if not all, of the postnatal stay in the hospital.

Wire Mothers from the early days where he was keeping his monkeys (and their isolation chambers) in a rickety old building just off campus. Later as his work got more attention he had to move out of the condemned building and into a proper lab. He also had to work under greater scrutiny.

The work was inhumane and controversial — no argument there. But I think it was a necessary evil to move away from the worst of the parenting advice bandied about when my grand parents were new parents. I'm glad that those men and women who ignored the parenting advice back then were eventually vindicated. ( )

Ottaviani. Meconis. Monkeys. Behavioral psychology. What's not to like? ( )

Carl is a janitor cleaning up a lab that stumbles upon Harry Harlow, a psychologist. Harlow launches into a story of his famous wire mother experiments in the context of his life. At first Carl seems disinterested, but as he learns more about Harlow’s experiments he is surprised and engaged in the story. In a short, humorous comic Ottaviani explains the rather complicated findings from Harry Harlow’s experiment with monkeys and love. The story works particularly well as a graphic novel because the pictures make it easier for readers to understand the way the experiment worked (the difference between the wire and cloth mothers and what the different rooms that they placed the monkeys in looked like). The panels of black and white drawings are different sizes so each page looks different. Many of the panels have a sharp contrast between black and white, which makes them appealing to the eye, although it can take some extra time to decipher what is going on in some of the pictures. Ottaviani gives an accurate description of Harlow’s experiments as told by Harlow, making this an enlightening, engaging piece, and a perfect entry-point into a discussion about psychology. ( )