This novel was a fascinating read and focused on two intelligent, strong, colonial women - Elizabeth (Betsey) Macquarie and Elizabeth Macarthur. I knew about these women's husbands thanks to my Australian history studies, but I had no knowledge of their wives. Both Elizabeths displayed resourcefulness and resilience despite challenging circumstances. Not only did they support their husbands, but they both also played important roles in the development of colonial Australia.

Told from alternating points of view, "Elizabeth and Elizabeth" was a story of an unlikely friendship as the two women shared their lives, loves, tribulations, frustrations, fears and hopes with each other. Although from strikingly different backgrounds, the bond they developed lasted the rest of their lives and both women refused to allow their husbands' dislike for each other to impact on their friendship.

I loved the rich, historical detail the author brought to this novel. Not only did readers get a strong sense of place, but they are also given an insight into the beginnings of Australia which I found compelling. A very enjoyable read. ( )

All too often history books are either silent on the contributions made by women or these contributions are incorrectly attributed to the men in their lives. All too often the real stories of women as individuals, their ideas and opinions, their drive, determination and personal sacrifice, are lost to history. It is in this context that I deeply admired and connected with Elizabeth & Elizabeth, Sue Williams’ ambition to fill this void fictionally.

Alternating chapter narratives draw out the likely differences in the two Elizabeth’s outlook and perspectives, while the women themselves seek out similarities upon which to base a friendship. I felt the way Williams contrasted the womens’ innermost thoughts with their judicious words and actions (particularly in the early, tentative stages of their relationship) imbued authenticity and aided characterisation. Continue reading >> https://www.bookloverbookreviews.com/2021/01/elizabeth-elizabeth-by-sue-williams... ( )

Based on the lives of Elizabeth ‘Betsey’ Macquarie, the wife of Australian colonel governor Lachlan Macquarie, and Elizabeth Macarthur, the wife of a prosperous colonial woolgrower, Sue Williams blends fact with fiction to present an interesting story of adversity, courage, love, and friendship in Elizabeth & Elizabeth.

Thirty one year old Betsey Macquarie arrived in Sydneytown with her new husband, Lachlan, who was to replace Captain Bligh as governor, in December of 1809. Viewing the appointment as an adventure, with her keen interest in architecture, landscaping and social welfare, Betsey had hopes of working alongside her husband to grow the colony.

At the time of Betsey’s arrival in New South Wales, Elizabeth Macarthur, had been living in the colony for twenty years. Her husband John, a Corps officer and successful grazier had been called to England to answer charges of sedition for his role in unseating Captain Bligh, leaving Elizabeth to manage their home farm, three daughters, and Camden Park estate, where they raised their valuable flock of merino sheep.

In this novel Williams conjures a friendship between the two women that overlooks the political enmity of their husbands. Both intelligent, strong, and practical women, Elizabeth and Elizabeth grow to respect and admire one another despite their differences, and become confidantes. The friendship is delightfully rendered by Williams, and permits her to present a well-rounded picture of the ‘Elizabeth’s’ lives, disabusing history’s notion they were simply no more than extensions of their husbands.

History favours the role of men in the building of our nation, but Elizabeth & Elizabeth gives these two women credit for contributions to the betterment of the colony. Williams suggests Betsey was the driving force behind the design and construction of several of Sydneytown’s public buildings, including The Courthouse and St James Church, the ‘Rum’ Hospital, and The Female Factory in Parramatta, and the development of what is now known as The Royal Botanic Gardens. Her support of her husband was also crucial to his many accomplishments as governor, despite the opposition he faced from ‘exclusivists’. Elizabeth Macarthur’s role in developing the family’s wool export business is better recognised today, though her husband continues to garner the lions share of credit. In her husband’s long absence from the colony however, she ably managed their extensive holdings, and oversaw the improvement of the merino flock that solidified their fortune.

Well-written, rich in historical detail and engaging, Elizabeth & Elizabeth is a lovely novel and recommended reading especially for those interested in Australia’s past. ( )