Fun to read. ( )

While I like the premise of the book and series, I have to say it's not a favorite of mine. I think this is mostly due to the relationship between the main character and the ghost. Too much animosity, and the ghost isn't the most likeable character. But I'll read the next in the series when it arrives and hope this improves. The mysteries were good, although one was fairly predictable. ( )

http://www.girllostinabook.com/2013/04/review-to-sketch-thief-by-sharon-pape.htm... ( )

Series: 2nd in the Portrait of Crime Mysteries

Sensuality: n/a

Mystery sub-genre: Private Detective, Paranormal

Main Characters: Rory (Aurora) McCain - a police sketch artist

Setting: Modern day, Suffolk County New York

Obtained Book Through: Publisher for honest review

Rory is now working full time as a private investigator. She is also adjusting to living with the ghost of 1878 Federal Marshal Ezekiel Drummond, aka Zeke. He is old fashioned, stubborn and cantankerous. Dogs and Ghosts don't get along well together so when a stray dog shows up at the house, Rory is quick to take it to the house listed on the tags. This good deed brings her to the murder of Brenda, the dog's just deceased owner. Brenda's other pet, a Maltese is missing. Hobo, the mixed breed, comes home with Rory which makes Zeke unhappy.

A friend of Brenda's hires Rory to investigate a rash of pure-bred dog thefts on the thought that Brenda died from a dog theft gone wrong. Rory will work the dog theft angle while the police work Brenda's death.

For the second book in the series the characters are developing nicely. I feel like I know Rory better after this book, and I am growing fond of her. Of course Ezekial Drummond is still a headstrong entity making her life difficult, but I really appreciate how we see them both trying to make their situation work. Hobo is a great addition to the cast and I already adore him.

Don't let the plot of finding dog-nappers fool you. Rory receives threats and one threat is carried out. There are some tense scenes and "whodunit" is not very cut and dry. This series is enjoyable for its engaging mystery and interesting characters with humor and a few twists. I was very tempted to list this as a cozy because it really is even though Rory is a PI.

One feature I liked in the first book continues in this one. Occasionally a chapter is devoted to Zeke's last investigation that got him killed. Rory is trying to help solve this for Zeke since his own unsolved murder appears to be keeping him here.

Often times a second book after a successful debut novel is hard to pull off. I am happy to report that I felt this book was a great follow up and definitely consider myself a fan now.

Join me at my mystery book blog:
http://mysterysuspence.blogspot.com ( )

When PI Rory McCain returns a dog that wandered into her yard, she doesn't expect to find the mutt's owner, Brenda Hartley, dead in the middle of the kitchen floor. Not wanting Hobo to go to a shelter, she takes him home, much to the annoyance of her partner, the ghost of one-time US marshal Zeke Drummond. The antipathy goes both ways: Hobo is frightened of the spectral lawman.

Having been the person to find the body, Rory would like to search for the killer, but as a private investigator, she can't unless someone hires her to do it.

When a friend of Brenda's, a dog breeder named Tina Kovack, hires Rory to find the dead woman's other dog, a purebred Maltese that wasn't found at Brenda's house. Tina is certain that Tootsie, was stolen by the person who killed Brenda. Rory isn't sure if she agrees, but she takes the case, because it means that while she's searching for the dognapper(s), she can also hunt for Brenda's killer.

Zeke Drummond's spirit remains earthbound because he wants to know who killed him, and he is physically unable to investigate on his own. He is a non-threatening character, who just happens to be unable to manifest outside the house, although he's pretty good at doing internet searches.

Zeke's sensibilities are very 19th Century though, while Rory is very much a self-sufficient 21st Century woman, and they do clash over societal proprieties. As a result, there's more humor here than spookiness, and especially with the addition of Hobo, and Rory's sleuth-wannabe Aunt Helene. ( )