Kathleen Stock

A few quotes and notes ...

“So: it follows from the logic of [Judith] Butler’s worldview [social constructionism] not only that there are not two naturally pre-given, stable biological sexes, but also that there are no pre-given facts about natural selection. There is no sexual reproduction. There are no pre-given chemical elements or biological species. There is no climate change, at least not as commonly understood. There are no molecules, atoms, or quarks. There are no viruses and no bacteria; no successful drugs nor placebos. … ” (p63)

No wonder social constructionism is so appealing: knowledge doesn’t matter; learning about anything is useless—don’t bother.

“And an advertisement for the American Mariposa Health clinic, which provides ‘gender-affirming hormone therapy, from anywhere’, exhorts prospective clients to ‘Live your authentic life’. (p113)

Imagine that slogan for Prozac: live your authentic life.

“In this context, treating males with female gender identities as women in every possible context … sends a contemptuously dismissive message to women already conscious of unequal treatment of their interests. This messages says: the interests of males with female gender identities are more important than yours.” (p160)

Yeah.

“As trans scholar Jack (then Judith) Halberstam wrote in 1998: ‘If adolescence for boys represents a rite of passage … and an ascension to some version (however attenuated) of social power, for girls, adolescence is a lesson in restraint, punishment, and repression.'” (p192).

Indeed. (And no wonder girls don’t want to be girls.)

“A 2015 survey found the average sixteen-to twenty-five-year-old woman spends over five hours a week taking selfies.” (p233)

Seriously? We used to call such women airheads.… (más)

Solidly researched and solidly argued, the book looks at the current trans trend and the impact it is having on women. The author details the ways in which feminism is failing women by insisting feminism is for everyone, not just women. She discusses many incidents that have occurred within the past few years as men transition and make their way into women's shelters, women's prisons, women's sports, and other formerly women-only spaces. There are areas of the book where I disagree with the author, but since I never expect to agree with anyone 100%, and since I am a mature professional woman, I will deal with my disagreements in ways that do not include sending her threatening emails or making her quit her job. Yes, the author has suffered immensely from writing this book; her bravery is as powerful as her research and her writing.… (más)