Graham Lord (1943–2015)

It's possible I'm being too harsh on this book for the rating, but by the end, I became extremely annoyed with the author and his suppositions and assumptions. It seemed to me that if he couldn't comprehend something, then it couldn't be so, and he obsessed about little things. I can't tell you how tired I became reading about what the occupation of Alf Wight's father might have been. It also seemed repetitive.

Now, aside from those flaws, the book was very interesting. I was fascinated by the fact that much of the Herriot lore was fiction so to speak, just as the Laura Ingalls Wilder books are. Does that bother me? I'm not sure that it does. I think these books, just as Wilder's, tell a bigger story than that of the author. They encompass a time, a place and a people and make them live for us. So whether or not some of the details and events are switched around or played with doesn't really matter because the essence is there.… (más)