Salma El-Wardany
Autor de These Impossible Things
Obras de Salma El-Wardany
Alles, was wir uns nicht sagen 1 copia
Etiquetado
Conocimiento común
Todavía no hay datos sobre este autor en el Conocimiento Común. Puedes ayudar.
Miembros
Reseñas
These impossible things : [a novel] por Salma El-Wardany
Loved this book. The characters are vivid and fully dimensional. The plot is compelling. I was really wanting to meet these three women in person!
This is a novel about culture, religion and relationships. The three principle characters are young Muslim women wrestling with complex personal lives in part because of restrictions they feel because of religious beliefs. I am sure this book will be totally relevant to the author's young Muslim readers. Trying to balance pressures of family and culture with feelings you have to live your life according to what is in your heart. I loved almost all the book except the end. It kind of peters out.
These Impossible Things is a story of friendship, faith, values and growing up seen through the eyes of three British Muslim women – Jenna, Malak and Bilquis (Kees). As the women move from study to work and life as adults, they encounter many difficult moments that could have been easier if they were still friends after an argument.
The reader first meets the trio while they are still at university. Growing up in the same community, they are aware of the expectations their parents have on keeping their faith and marrying a good Muslim man. At university, both Kees and Malak have non-Muslim boyfriends and Malak and Jenna both drink alcohol. After Kees and Malak finish university (Jenna remains, studying medicine), they need to make some difficult choices. Malak breaks up with her boyfriend Jacob while Kees continues hers with Harry but keeps it a secret from her parents. It results in an argument about duty, faith and the happily ever after their parents want that cause Kees and Malak to stop talking to each other. Malak decides to go to Egypt to repair her broken heart, and falls in love – but with consequences that will change her. Kees and Harry both start work as lawyers, but the stress of keeping their relationship secret from Kees’ family proves too difficult to bear. It results her family cutting off all contact just as she is working harder than ever. Jenna is adrift without her friends and goes to seek pleasure wherever she can find it with dangerous, life changing results. All the women are hurting alone, can the pain drive them back together?
This is a fantastic story. It explores both coming of age in different ways, secrets, duty and female friendships. It is also not afraid to explore serious topics such as abuse (sexual, physical and psychological) and the conflict between faith and family. Salma El-Wardany handles both the serious and thorny topics exceptionally well. Religion (Islam and also Catholicism) also plays a role in the novel, but it’s not heavy handed. It’s explained as a part of each character’s life, drawing solace and peace, as well as being hard to bear in crises of faith and family. The role of family and expectations of the community was also described very well, with differences between the women’s families. This was further contrasted with Harry’s Catholic family, particularly his mother, who was so eager to assist with the nikah that she went quite OTT in a not-always-good way. The pain of Kees’ family cutting her off was visceral, with the ending being incredibly emotional. The guilt of each character for hurting her family, faith and neglecting friendships was strong, but not overpowering. Overall, the relationships are portrayed in all their messy complexity and the characters make mistakes, but overall it’s about friendship, love and support for each other.
Thank you to Hachette for the copy of this book. My review is honest.
http://samstillreading.wordpress.com… (más)
The reader first meets the trio while they are still at university. Growing up in the same community, they are aware of the expectations their parents have on keeping their faith and marrying a good Muslim man. At university, both Kees and Malak have non-Muslim boyfriends and Malak and Jenna both drink alcohol. After Kees and Malak finish university (Jenna remains, studying medicine), they need to make some difficult choices. Malak breaks up with her boyfriend Jacob while Kees continues hers with Harry but keeps it a secret from her parents. It results in an argument about duty, faith and the happily ever after their parents want that cause Kees and Malak to stop talking to each other. Malak decides to go to Egypt to repair her broken heart, and falls in love – but with consequences that will change her. Kees and Harry both start work as lawyers, but the stress of keeping their relationship secret from Kees’ family proves too difficult to bear. It results her family cutting off all contact just as she is working harder than ever. Jenna is adrift without her friends and goes to seek pleasure wherever she can find it with dangerous, life changing results. All the women are hurting alone, can the pain drive them back together?
This is a fantastic story. It explores both coming of age in different ways, secrets, duty and female friendships. It is also not afraid to explore serious topics such as abuse (sexual, physical and psychological) and the conflict between faith and family. Salma El-Wardany handles both the serious and thorny topics exceptionally well. Religion (Islam and also Catholicism) also plays a role in the novel, but it’s not heavy handed. It’s explained as a part of each character’s life, drawing solace and peace, as well as being hard to bear in crises of faith and family. The role of family and expectations of the community was also described very well, with differences between the women’s families. This was further contrasted with Harry’s Catholic family, particularly his mother, who was so eager to assist with the nikah that she went quite OTT in a not-always-good way. The pain of Kees’ family cutting her off was visceral, with the ending being incredibly emotional. The guilt of each character for hurting her family, faith and neglecting friendships was strong, but not overpowering. Overall, the relationships are portrayed in all their messy complexity and the characters make mistakes, but overall it’s about friendship, love and support for each other.
Thank you to Hachette for the copy of this book. My review is honest.
http://samstillreading.wordpress.com… (más)
Malak, Kees, and Jenna have been friends since childhood in the tight knit and nurturing Islamic culture of the UK. As they embark on their adult lives, a sudden falling out one evening separates them temporarily. They begin to build lives apart, but, in crisis, are drawn back to one another.
This was yet another novel that took a while for me to engage with and really appreciate. Initially, I thought the friends, for their age, to be quite adolescent, or at least their conversation seemed so.
Beautifully written, the author tackles some very difficult topics. There is so much here…the pull of family and culture, gender roles, abuse, the strength of friendship, and what, to me, has always been the tyranny of religion. It is an engrossing, rewarding read. There is a technique the author employs that I really like. As she told the story from each woman’s POV, she also related what was going in other related peoples’ lives at the same time.
Thanks to NetGalley and Grand Central Publishing for providing the DRC.… (más)
This was yet another novel that took a while for me to engage with and really appreciate. Initially, I thought the friends, for their age, to be quite adolescent, or at least their conversation seemed so.
Beautifully written, the author tackles some very difficult topics. There is so much here…the pull of family and culture, gender roles, abuse, the strength of friendship, and what, to me, has always been the tyranny of religion. It is an engrossing, rewarding read. There is a technique the author employs that I really like. As she told the story from each woman’s POV, she also related what was going in other related peoples’ lives at the same time.
Thanks to NetGalley and Grand Central Publishing for providing the DRC.… (más)
Premios
Estadísticas
- Obras
- 3
- Miembros
- 155
- Popularidad
- #135,097
- Valoración
- 4.2
- Reseñas
- 4
- ISBNs
- 14
- Idiomas
- 1