When Dr. Dan Hamilton, Stewarts Falls' veterinarian, attends the house warming of his friends, Carolyn and David Reid, he is surprised to discover that Cindy Howard, his former girlfriend and the woman he'd hoped to marry, is catering the occasion. He is confused when she acts as if he had treated her badly. After all, she was the one who had left him without a word of explanation. Mystified, he leaves the party with his receptionist, Gina, whom he has been seeing casually since Cindy left him. Carolyn and David, convinced that Cindy and Dan are meant for each other, decide to help them resolve their differences. But none of their efforts are as effective as those of a puppy named Crash. From the moment he tumbles into their lives, Cindy and Dan struggle to understand the reasons for their separation and to reclaim their love. Can the cupids succeed in uniting these star-crossed lovers before the holidays end and the magic of the season disappears?