Sarah Colby's romantic heart believes there's a man for her somewhere. She's determined to find her "soul mate." During a "girls' night out" at a Louisville bar, Sarah's two former college roommates urge her to "kiss a lot of toads" if she wants to find Prince Charming. Hoping to make up for lost time, twenty-four-year-old Sarah practices on several good-looking guys. One of the unsuspecting "toads" is wealthy restaurateur Lane Williams, a guy with a great aversion to settling down. Lane can't be bothered with romance. His past twenty years has been one of long hours and sacrifice, and he's had enough responsibility to last a lifetime. Clearly, the sexy, young woman, who wants only marriage, is trouble to his equilibrium. As they work together to pull off an important charity party, Lane finds himself susceptible to her charms...and much, much more.