Lenny is managing a failing bookstore and struggling to keep his promise of fidelity to Dave. He flirts relentlessly with grad student Ian until he discovers that Ian's ambivalence masks something personal and devastating. Caught up in a whirlwind of sex and lies, Lenny and Dave's relationship spins out of control. Lenny clings to Dave's unassuming manhood in hopes of keeping himself grounded, but when another seductive stranger becomes too tempting to resist, Lenny and Dave face the ultimate challenge.