While fighting nightmares of the one she once loved, Sarah has been tucked away safely for months after leaving Cain's island and is adjusting to life in a small village thousands of miles from her friends and family. With Justin to protect her Sarah is thrilled to be falling back into the normal life she had once worked so hard for, starting college and following her own path. During a class on myth and folklore Sarah is lured to a fourteenth century Castle by the stories of its haunting mistress. Sarah soon finds out that stories of myth and legend are often held in some form of truth. After being attacked by the Castle's resident supernatural fixture Sarah is forced to face the things that have kept her terrified and in hiding as she struggles to protect herself and keep Justin safely at her side.