Jacqueline Yallop

When I think of model villages I think of those miniaturised places that children love so much as they peer in through the tiny windows and look at the treasures within. But the title of model villages was given to those places that were built in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries by philanthropists and employers for families working in factories and mines. These places are scattered across the country and are as well-known as Port Sunlight, Saltaire and Bournville.

Part historical examination and part travelogue, Yallop provides a scholarly overview of each of these villages and the effect that they had on the social scene of the day, coupled with a personal view of how they sit in the modern landscape now. She considers the effect that the Arts and Crafts movement had on the worker’s cottages, the rising concerns that the great and the good had about poverty and the political system that gave birth to these communities.

It is an interesting book, these places have become embedded in our cultural landscape. The original factories and industries that these places supported are long gone now but some are as popular to live in today as they were when built. Yallop brings her expertise and personal experience to the book; she worked giving guided tours at a village in the high fells, and it shows as it is eloquent and well researched. What doesn’t work for me though is it that the books feels disjointed. A chapter starts at a particular village, then wanders off to other places before going back to visit to the original village. It feels a bit disjointed and loses some of the fluidity that could have made it so much better. I did like the travel parts of her book though; her visits to the villages are richly descriptive and full of warmth.… (más)

The author made a huge risk of writing this because it tackles the stigma that the Catholic Church isn't perfect like what we assumed it to be. The author is really brave on writing a story about some members of the religious community who vowed celibacy yet they had issues like this. Moreover, she even incorporate on how the Church sometimes even hide and protect them just because they don't want people to be aware of it. A big round of applause for the author on making a leap and writing something like this.… (más)

Of the cities profiled in this book, I read only the chapters on Port Sunlight (Liverpool) and Portmeirion (Wales), as they were the ones that interested me most. And of these two chapters, the Portmeirion chapter came the closest to fulfilling my expectations for the book as a whole: it talked about how the city had come to be, the various architectural styles on display, and how the use of the city has changed over the years. I was, however, surprised to find that the cult series The Prisoner (which filmed exterior shots here) warranted only one sentence in this chapter. The current status of the village as a tourist destination is mentioned, but only in a general sense. The Port Sunlight chapter, meanwhile, jumped around a bit more chronologically and went on historical explanation tangents, such as that related to the beginnings of advertising. I also wish that the photo inserts had been in colour. All the villages look the same in black and white.

Overall, this book fits my rating category "Almost liked it, but not quite". Those with more patience for tangents may have better luck with it.… (más)