James K. Wellman
Autor de Evangelical vs. Liberal: the clash of Christian cultures in the Pacific Northwest
Sobre El Autor
James K. Wellman Jr. is Associate Professor and Chair of the Comparative Religion Program at Jackson School of International Studies, University of Washington.
Obras de James K. Wellman
Etiquetado
Conocimiento común
Todavía no hay datos sobre este autor en el Conocimiento Común. Puedes ayudar.
Miembros
Reseñas
Estadísticas
- Obras
- 5
- Miembros
- 92
- Popularidad
- #202,476
- Valoración
- 3.8
- Reseñas
- 3
- ISBNs
- 14
- Idiomas
- 1
"Who were these dangerous fundamentalists who smoked cigars, indulged in French cuisine, and who were apparently determined to take over downtown Moscow?" Haha!! I'll bet I have a good guess...
--
I didn't find the book to live up quite to the B&C review's promise. As a presentation of the respective moral worldviews of liberal and evangelical Christians in the Pacific Northwest, and how the respective groups' views on Jesus Christ, the Bible, ritual, prayer, evangelism and missions, and political issues are logically consistent with those worldviews, it's pretty good. Wellman doesn't conceal his self-identity as a liberal Protestant, but he succeeds fairly well at letting his evangelical subjects express their views and appreciating the nuance therein. He also has some interesting ideas on why evangelical churches in the PNW are thriving and most liberal churches are not, and how this, too, is consistent with the respective moral worldviews -- basically, evangelicals have an unwaveringly "entrepreneurial" approach to the faith, by which he means a commitment to reproducing the faith in their children, their communities, and the world, whereas most of the liberals he interviewed were, at best, ambivalent about sharing their faith and growing their churches.
I felt the depth of analysis was a little lacking in places. I don't think Wellman considers himself a theologian or historian, but, especially given that he's an ordained Presbyterian minister, his few remarks on the Reformed subset of evangelicalism were confusing: "the Christian Reformed movement [sic?]...is theologically and socially less conservative" than the churches profiled in the book. Granted, it's a little bit out of the evangelical mainstream, but "less conservative"? Really?
Of course, readers of various backgrounds would probably have similar critiques and nuances to suggest. For the most part, I'd still recommend this, particularly to Christians who want to get a handle on how the "other side" thinks. I certainly found it reflective of my experience as an evangelical trained in predominantly liberal environments. Though I also found it depressing, as it confirmed that there's little common ground...it's so difficult to communicate with Christians whose presuppositions are so opposite your own, no matter how much you'd like to.… (más)