Louise Sharland

3.5 stars - Great read. The author has a fantastic writing style. The last 25% of the book or so (when the poetry retreat starts) is kind of slow, and the 'evidence' Kate thinks she's gathered really is just opinion isn't it? The biggest thing that annoyed me was that "Diving Fish" was supposedly Michael's swim coach. But then during the canoeing she said she couldn't go because she couldn't swim. (But she was the swim coach?) Then later when they fell in the Loch, suddenly she was swimming. Then somehow something "pulled her down"... doesn't seem plausible.

Also Kate didn't seem to grieve much when her mother died? And she claims she left her husband but I don't think HE knew that.... lol.

I did LOVE that none of the book's locations were in the United States! Loved the Canada-UK connection also!… (más)