Joel Scott (2)

I read this book weeks ago but have procrastinated over writing a review. On the one hand, Scott's description of all things to do with sailing and as well the south sea locales were interesting and authentic sounding. The plot was also intriguing - up to a point. Where the novel ran into trouble for me was when it came to his characterizations particularly of the female characters. His male protagonist is impulsive, macho, a bit arrogant, and very physical. All good and interesting. but when he first encountered the main female character, who he mistakenly believed was responsible for vandalizing his boat - his response went way beyond what that belief would have justified. His response was callow, boorish, and cruel. And even later on when the mistake was cleared up, he doesn't apologize. Given the female character's backstory, their romantic linking up is just not believable for me. I don't want to give any spoilers - but I have to say, Scott has a very poor grasp on how women would behave, particularly after being assaulted. As a result, the resolution was not satisfying - was actually a bit cartoonish - because it hinged on both the author's and the character's shallow understanding of women. It was kind of offensive really. But maybe this was supposed to be a man's man story, and so intended to appeal specifically to that reading audience...… (más)