Imagen del autor

Ira Progoff (1921–1997)

Autor de At a Journal Workshop

25+ Obras 1,467 Miembros 10 Reseñas 3 Preferidas

Sobre El Autor

Obras de Ira Progoff

At a Journal Workshop (1975) 571 copias

Obras relacionadas

La nube del no saber (1957)algunas ediciones; algunas ediciones1,607 copias
Mysticism (1955) — Prólogo, algunas ediciones1,051 copias

Etiquetado

Conocimiento común

Miembros

Reseñas

This seemed like a great book, full of ideas, until I tried doing some of its exercises. It's very formulaic and prescriptive, doesn't encourage free-form journaling.

It didn't work with the way I like to think and how like to journal.
 
Denunciada
mykl-s | 5 reseñas más. | Feb 25, 2023 |
I gave this book a try roughly twenty-five years ago and soon put it aside. I now realize what the problem was. This is one of those books that reads like the script Progoff may have used in a live workshop setting. A speaker often restates the same point in various ways to make sure that point has gotten across. A writer doesn’t need to. When he does anyway, he risks having his reader’s eyes glaze over, and the reader risks missing valuable material.
The primary beneficiaries of this book, then, would be those who attended a Dialogue House workshop, where Progoff or another facilitator introduced intensive journaling. Having this text would be a handy way of refreshing its method for continued work on the journal after the workshop.
Nevertheless, there is useful material here for those of us who are on our own as we work with the raw material of our lives to detect its movement through time with the hope of integrating its varied facets and experiences. The book reflects throughout Progoff’s conviction that each individual life is a potential work of art.
This may sound solipsistic, even narcissistic, but balanced against it is an image Progoff uses that I found enlightening: Our exploration of our lives, with its excavation of ever-deeper layers, is like going down a well. When we reach the bottom, we discover that this well is fed by the same underground springs as many other wells. We come away from this experience not only with a deeper recognition of the unique course of our personal lives but also its connectivity with the rest of humanity.
… (más)
 
Denunciada
HenrySt123 | 5 reseñas más. | Jul 19, 2021 |
Half the book is formatted so that one page is a "meditation log" which the reader is supposed to write on, and the facing page is a fustian, zen-like, contrived poem; for example: "Everything we behold/ We draw into our Self./ So we draw it into our Self./The underground stream/Is one with us." I can't. I just can't. Even though he's a Jungian.
½
 
Denunciada
deckla | May 29, 2018 |
 
Denunciada
Baku-X | otra reseña | Jan 10, 2017 |

También Puede Gustarte

Estadísticas

Obras
25
También por
2
Miembros
1,467
Popularidad
#17,514
Valoración
3.9
Reseñas
10
ISBNs
43
Idiomas
3
Favorito
3

Tablas y Gráficos