A Roman à clef* of Sci-Fi Writers
Review of the Penzler Publishers American Mystery Classics eBook edition (July 23, 2019) of the Duell, Sloan and Pearce hardcover original (1942).

This is the way it was in Southern California just before the war, when science fiction was being given its present form by such authors as Robert A. Heinlein (still the undisputed Master), Cleve Cartmill, Jack Williamson, Edmond Hamilton, Henry Kuttner, C. L. Moore, and many others. (And this is as wise a place as any to add hastily that no character in this novel is based specifically on any actual writer—nor is any character quite devoid of some factual basis.) - from the Afterword by author Antony Boucher.

Although Antony Boucher's Afterword tries to distance him from direct 1-to-1 correlations between his fictional characters in Rocket to the Morgue and the real-life science fiction authors they were based on, F. Paul Wilson's Introduction to this 2019 AMC edition states them explicitly. You can also read them in a section of the Wikipedia entry for the book.

So the fun of this is primarily the fictional depictions of authors such as Robert A. Heinlein and L. Ron Hubbard as murder suspects Austin Carter and D. Vance Wimpole in the book. The Wimpole character is already portrayed as a shifty, lecherous and unlikeable character, and this is well before the time when Hubbard invented his Scientology grift in 1953.

See cover at https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/9/92/RocketToTheMorgue.jpg
Cover of the original first edition published under the pseudonym H.H. Holmes by Duell, Sloan and Pearce in 1942. Image sourced from Wikipedia.

The detective Terry Marshal and his consultant Sister Ursula play rather minor roles throughout. It is a bit of a locked room mystery with various murder attempts on Hilary Foulkes, the son and literary executor of (fictional) sci-fi author Fowler Foulkes. Foulkes Jr. is despised by the rest of the literary community for exorbitant fees charged for the use of his father's copyright material. That scenario reminded me of the story of Stephen Joyce, the grandson of James Joyce, who held a similar iron hand over his grandfather's estate until the works entered the public domain in 2012. However, the situation in Rocket to the Morgue (1942) pre-dates the litigations and bans of the Joyce estate, which were mostly in the late 20th century.

Overall, this was goofy fun with most of the drama and interest coming from its real-world parallels.

Footnote
* From French: a novel with a key. Usually a novel where pseudonyms are used for the names of real life people. Sometimes the plot is a fictionalized version of events which actually happened. One therefore needs a "key" i.e. the secret code to identify who or what someone or something is based on.

Trivia and Links
There is a short section in this book devoted to a listing of "What If" speculative or alternate history literature, a sub-genre of fantasy and sci-fi. It was especially interesting to learn that Winston S. Churchill once wrote a speculative fiction piece If Lee Had Not Won the Battle of Gettysburg, written as if by a future historian in a world where the North had lost the American Civil War. The piece originally appeared in Scribner's Magazine in 1930 and was later collected in the anthology If It Had Happened Otherwise (1931).

This edition of Rocket to the Morgue is part of the Otto Penzler American Mystery Classics series (2018-ongoing). There is a related Goodreads Listopia here with 57 books listed as of early June 2024. There are currently 72 titles listed at the Mysterious Press online bookshop. The official website for the series at Penzler Publishers seems to show only the most recent and upcoming titles. ( )

Note: I accessed a digital review copy of this book through Edelweiss. ( )

Anthony Boucher is best known in SF circles as the first editor of Fantasy and Science Fiction. He pushed for higher writing standards in science fiction. Outside SF he was known as a mystery writer.

Rocket to the Morgue is NOT a science fiction mystery. It is a locked room mystery in the milieu of early (1942) California SF fandom. It is a sequel to Nine by Nine, another locked room mystery, that introduced Lieutenant Marshall and the Holmes-like nun, Sister Ursula. Reader comments are not too kind to Nine by Nine, but I found this novel to be a solid entry in the locked room canon. There are many red herrings but it plays fair.

Rocket was known for including many real science fiction authors and editors -- including Boucher -- mostly by reference, but sometimes lightly disguised as peripheral characters.

What I found most interesting was the appendix written in 1951 where Boucher reveals that Marshall's introduction to and eventual conversion to reading SF mirrored Boucher's personal journey.

Recommended as a fun read, if you can get past the fact that every female character is introduced by their body type. ( )

Science fiction is in its infancy, and one of its earliest legends is Fowler Foulkes, who created the immortal Dr. Derringer. Fowler’s son, Hilary, administers the Foulkes estate with a view to wringing every penny out of reprints, not even extending favours to the nuns who would make a Braille version for blind readers. With such a talent for making enemies, it’s not surprising that someone would try to kill Hilary. What is surprising is the locked-room nature of the attempt—and it will take all the ingenuity of Detective Marshall and his occasional confidante, Sister Ursula, to figure out who attempted-to-do-it.

This book is not only a mystery novel; it’s a portrait of the sci-fi community in the United States in the late 1930s. Boucher himself makes a cameo appearance, while several of his friends appear as caricatures or as composite characters. It’s a light, wry sort of mystery, both in terms of writing style and in terms of plot. I’m not really one for the locked-room mystery, because I don’t have the faintest hope of guessing whodunnit, but this story was agreeable enough. I’d recommend it if you like light Golden Age mysteries, mysteries about writers, or perhaps the Anthony Horowitz books where he is a character in his own story. (Or if you thought Horowitz’s idea a bit over the top, you might like this better, because Boucher appears only sparingly in his own book.) ( )

Rocket to the Morgue by Anthony Boucher is one of the classic mysteries re-printed by Penzler Publishers under their American Mystery Classics imprint. Writing in the 1940s, Boucher was known for his versatile talents within Science Fiction, Fantasy and Mystery fiction. A prolific contributor to each of these genres, Boucher utilized his familiarity with the publishing world to add depth and humor to his work. Rocket to the Morgue is a classic detective novel representative of its time with all the requisite elements: an insightful and quirky detective, a plethora of potential suspects from all levels of society, and a seemingly unsolvable locked door case to confound the police. What distinguishes this novel, however, is its setting within the incestuous and often cut-throat world of Los Angeles pulp fiction. Boucher provides his inside view of the experience of a writer in the pressurized atmosphere that he himself inhabited. Along the way, he does not neglect to provide a charming, fast-paced and well-plotted mystery to challenge any armchair sleuth. Delightful for its reflection of a revered era of detective fiction, and surprising for its unexpectedly modern approaches to class/gender stereotypes, Penzler Press has done a favor to modern mystery fans by introducing Rocket to the Morgue and Boucher to a new crop of readers.

Thanks to NetGalley and Penzler Press for an ARC of this book in return for an unbiased review. ( )