Pulse en una miniatura para ir a Google Books.
Cargando... Los inicios de la ciencia occidental (1992)por David C. Lindberg
Cargando...
Inscríbete en LibraryThing para averiguar si este libro te gustará. Actualmente no hay Conversaciones sobre este libro. In 1970 I studied the history of science under the tutelage of Professor David C. Lindberg. Some years later he published this text which was considered the first successful attempt to present a unified account of both ancient and medieval science in a single volume. It successfully captures the advance of science over that period with detailed accounts of the origin and growth of significant aspects of scientific thought. ( ) The Beginnings of Western Science: The European Scientific Tradition in Philosophical, Religious and Institutional Context, 600 BC to AD 1450. By David C Lindberg. If you wish to understand how teachings from antiquity vitally affected the middle ages then you could do no better than reading Lindbergs book. He claims that no previous knowledge of the history is necessary to grasp his arguments and this may be so, but his book is no mere introduction. I found it invaluable for a clearer understanding of how the rediscovery of Aristotle's teachings in particular, shaped the thoughts of the medieval scholars. Lindberg recognises that the term Western Science in the title is misleading as what he is intent on exploring is natural philosophy; that is ancient and medieval attempts to investigate nature. His book therefore covers philosophy and religion as well as rigorously examining how ancient and medieval people viewed and understood their world. Lindberg aims to discuss the question of continuity between ancient and medieval science and so he must therefore demonstrate the achievements of the classical world. He starts further back than this with an overview of prehistoric, Babylonian and Egyptian science before launching into the teachings of Plato and Aristotle of ancient Greece. Philosophy, metaphysics, epistemology, motion, the workings of the cosmos are all examined in enough detail to enable Lindberg to draw out the essential differences between the teachings of Plato and his pupil Aristotle. He broadens out the picture with an overview of the Stoics and the Epicureans and their follows chapters on mathematics, astronomy, optics and weights, before a very good overview of Galen and the achievements of Hellenistic medicine. The Roman invasion of the Greek world and the subsequent amalgamation of Greek learning is very well explained, Lindberg comments: "Members of the Roman upper class had about the same level of interest in the fine points of Greek natural philosophy as the average American politician has in metaphysics and epistemology. At best their desire was as the Roman playwright Enius put it "To study philosophy but in moderation" The only surprise is that historians expected it to be otherwise" The Romans popularised Greek ideas, but Greek teaching survived in satellite towns like Alexandria in Egypt. The teachings of Plato tended to get the upper hand and with the advent of Christianity his pagan world view was more easily adapted by the early Christians. Lindberg follows this with an excellent overview of Islamic science and its mingling with Greek learning and then explains how such learning survived through the dark ages until a new burst of scholarly activity started again in the Carolingian Empire. Universities and other centres of learning became a feature of the twelfth century and Lindberg describes how classical texts were rediscovered, many of them having to be translated from the Arabic after surviving with commentary in the Islamic world. Aristotle became a huge influence and Lindberg skillfully tells how his teachings were adapted for use in the Christian world. This was because at the end of the day it was recognised by Christian scholars that this pagan knowledge was just too valuable to be ignored. Late medieval learning is then described especially in relation to how Aristotle's teachings were re-examined and expanded where necessary and there are further chapters on optics, cosmology, medicine, astronomy, astrology and alchemy. Finally Lindberg steps back to consider the legacy of medieval learning and expounds on the two polar views, which can be summed up as the continuity debate. Was there a gradual increase in knowledge from the middle ages up to the time of the scientific breakthroughs in the 17th and 18th centuries or was their a discontinuity and a need for a re-evaluation of learning before the leaps forward could take place? Lindberg says he is in the discontinuity camp and sets out his reasons. Throughout the book Lindberg emphasises that we should not look on the achievements of the classical and medieval worlds from a modern standpoint, We may think they got a lot wrong, but it worked for them and only by looking at the world through their eyes will we be able to understand and evaluate their achievements. The book is well annotated and there is an extensive bibliography. It is a bit text bookish, but Lindberg writes engagingly and it filled in some gaps in my knowledge sin reseñas | añadir una reseña
Referencias a esta obra en fuentes externas. Wikipedia en inglés (14)Este libro es el primer intento de dar una vision global de la ciencia en el mundo antiguo, de escribir una historia de la ciencia medieval en su conjunto, y de presentar una exposicion detallada y unificada del asunto en un unico volumen. En el, David C. Lindberg narra con energia el desarrollo de las ideas practicas e instituciones cientificas a las que dio lugar los albores del pensamiento humano, desde la filosofia presocratica griega hasta el escolasticismo medieval.Lindberg revisa los temas mas importantes de la historia de la ciencia antigua y medieval relativos a materias como las matematicas, la astronomia, la mecanica, la optica, la alquimia, la historia natural y la medicina. Ademas, ofrece un iluminador relato de la transmision del conocimiento cientifico desde la antigua Grecia al Islam y posteriormente a la Europa medieval. La prosa sencilla y vigorosa de Lindberg, la nitida estructura de su libro, satisfaran tanto a los especialistas como a los legos en la materia, proporcionandoles abundante informacion. A lo largo del libro, el autor presta especial atencion a los contextos culturales e institucionales en los que se creo y difundio el conocimiento cientifico y a los modos en que la filosofia y la religion influyeron en el contenido y la practica de la ciencia.Aunque se apoya en un amplio cuerpo de investigacion llevada a cabo en las ultimas decadas por diversos historiadores de la ciencia, de la filosofia y de la religion, Lindberg no duda en proponer nuevas interpretaciones y en aventurar opiniones prestas a resolver antiguas disputas historicas. Una impresionante coleccion de inusuales y excepcionales fotografias, mapas y figuras ilustran bellamente el texto. No se han encontrado descripciones de biblioteca. |
Debates activosNingunoCubiertas populares
Google Books — Cargando... GénerosSistema Decimal Melvil (DDC)509.4Natural sciences and mathematics General Science History, geographic treatment, biography EuropeClasificación de la Biblioteca del CongresoValoraciónPromedio:
¿Eres tú?Conviértete en un Autor de LibraryThing. |