Cute story. The artwork reminded me of Archie comics (I think since I've never actually read Archie comics). A good, light hearted romp. Nicely campy. ( )

This is aggressively bland. A group of children come together in a Scooby gang as they face a supernatural menace in old-time London. Sherlock Holmes is referenced in an unsatisfying way to justify the title. Tepid humor. Tepid scares. Nothing here distinguishes it from the all too numerous competition in the category of mild children's horror. ( )

I have been on something of a Holmes binge lately reading various graphic novels and books that take Doyle’s character and his life into various directions. Thankfully this latest incantation keeps up the good work in how that literary classic is presented both through the written and visual story.
Roger Langridge took something from a classic age and retold it with the same grace and beauty but in a way more modern readers will love. A diverse cast of various belief systems, genders, and races form the ragtag group of characters that will melt your heart as they solve a mystery only Holmes could tell it.

As great as the scene work, dialogue and characters are what adds that extra layer of beauty and depth are the illustrations by Andy Hirsch. They reminded me a bit of the way comics were done back in the age of Richie Rich and Archie. Those amusing and vibrant styles that exude the playfulness and joy captured within the written word on the pages.

It’s definitely a fun adaptation of the Holmes Legend and it’s perfect for all ages to enjoy. It’d be a great gateway for younger audiences who need an introduction to the mystery that is Sherlock Holmes. ( )

Note: I received a digital review copy of this book from the publisher through NetGalley. ( )