I was surprised at how readable this book turned out to be. I love reading about the early history of the British Isles anyway, but many books on this subject are a bit dry, best taken a few pages at a time in between more exciting books. This one, on the other hand, I read almost straight through and spent hours online looking up more information and photos afterwards because I was not ready yet to move on to the next book. ( )

From Pictland To Alba is a terrific study of late 1st millenium AD Scotland, drawing together in a brilliantly accessible way the competing societies of northern Britain. This is the 2nd book in the New Edinburgh series and is an outstanding contribution.

Woolf opens his account with an assessment of the living and societal arrangements of communities in the time period and this is an invaluable context that history books often miss. History is not just about kings but is also the summed efforts of those across a culture. Woolf also keeps the technical parts of the study simple including in explaining his sources though having notes on naming conventions at the start might be a little intimidating.

Woolf's narrative flows throughout despite crossing societies from Orkney to Normandy, and from Connacht to Sweden. The description of the balance of power between various Pictish, Gaelic, and British kingdoms is the most definitive around and the travails of each group are demonstrated logically and clearly. Woolf's narrative offers the reader the opportunity to make leaps of imagination to explain what is missed in the sources and Woolf is careful not to overplay what can be gleaned from existing information. In setting out possible options in areas where not quite enough is known, the reader can draw sensible conclusions on balance of probabilities that the rigorous narrative can not.

The arrival of the Vikings in this period is one of the crucial elements in the formation of the Scottish state and the explanation of the collapse of the Picts here is convincing. The role that religion played in uniting factions is fascinating and the continued battle for survival that ultimately forged Britain is set in the context of expanding Scandinavian and Germanic kingdoms.

The relationship with southern kingdoms is explained effectively and though it might have been nice to have more on Brunanburh, the context that Woolf sets shows just how definitive that battle for one was. Other battles are no doubt lost to history and Woolf shows how the conquest of Strathcylde by the Gaels remains a gap in our understanding but this work allows likely scenarios to be understood and for a solid picture of developments in Scotland to be pieced together.

The formatting of the book is a mixed bag. The use of text boxes is a nice way to get to grips with particular specifics though the editing of paragraphs around those boxes is not great as they sometimes have to be referred back to. The use of footnotes is more irritating though as Woolf intersperses references to other works with his own commentary on his text which disrupts the flow on the chance that a footnote instead contains a thoughtful aside.

Overall this is a superb work that should be recommended for anyone with an interest in the place and the period. ( )