Pulse en una miniatura para ir a Google Books.
Cargando... The Rise and Fall of Adam and Evepor Stephen Greenblatt
Books Read in 2019 (2,411) Cargando...
Inscríbete en LibraryThing para averiguar si este libro te gustará. Actualmente no hay Conversaciones sobre este libro. A terrific learning experience. Comments on the credibility of the Adam and Eve narrative run from cover to cover: major voices from history include Augustine's literal interpretation, Voltaire's sarcasm, Darwin's proof of evolution and Mark Twain's hilarious Adam and Eve diary entries - they're the gems of the narrative. The misogyny inherent in the Adam and Eve origin narrative is unrelenting. ( ) The story of Adam and Even had a profound effect on western civilization and western civilization had a profound effect on how we currently view the story today. Stephen Greenblatt looks in depth how St. Augustine, John Milton, and others shaped the conventional interpretations of their story. He also looks in depth at the people that began raising questions about the story. In particular, he looks at the development of geology and evolutionary biology radically impacted how people now look at the story. Finally, the book includes a brief summary of other creation myths and other interpretations of the Biblical creation story. Although the material of the book is sometimes a challenge, it is well written and well worth the effort. One warning about the Kindle edition of the book: the illustrations are not really sharp enough to enjoy. As I was also finishing up Philip Pullman's Dark Materials trilogy (full disclosure: I am personally in entire agreement with Mr. Pullman's thoughts on organized religion), Greenblatt's book was a fascinating adjunct. He explores in detail this age-old, so-familiar story, but casts new light upon it by marshalling examples of other origin tales, contemporaneous and otherwise, and placing it in a complex historical and literary context. For example, did you know there were versions in existence in ancient times where Eve and the serpent were the *heroes* - rightfully resisting God's selfish prohibition and bestowing a fuller knowledge on humanity? Or that some scholars offered interpretations suggesting that Adam willingly shared the fruit with Eve because he knew he would otherwise be so lonely and miserable without the mate who had brought such joy to him? It is refreshing to find Greenblatt enthusiastically unearthing defenses and alternative interpretations to absolve That Woman of all the blame for the mess humanity has been in ever since. He weaves in examples of Adam and Eve in art, depicting the varying ways they are presented and understood. He explores the knotty problem faced by theologians in deciding whether the First Couple are meant as literal, anthropological facts, or allegories. As the centuries unroll and knowledge of the world expands, new questions must be wrestled with: what about all those indigenous people who came to the attention of the European explorers of the New World? Damned? Innocents? Shameless? Kudos to Greenblatt for his tribute to the Dominican Bartolome de la Casas who wrote powerfully and in anguish over the atrocities committed against the indigenous people by the Spaniards and did his best to protect them. Who DID Cain marry, anyway? Finally, along comes Darwin to really wreck the temple... many centuries after a Roman named Lucretius postulated an "atomist" history whereby living beings developed in tiny tiny increments of chance over enormous spans of time, and were NOT invented and set loose by a god or gods somewhere. Greenblatt also writes with great admiration (and length) about John Milton and his Paradise Lost: Milton creates a subtle, complex, and oh-so-human pair of people that in whom we recognize our own frailties. It's still a great story, and Greenblatt can offer no higher praise than that this fairy tale has become... literature. Having partaken of the knowledge Greenblatt has offered in this book, I feel like a better human being. A good read. A few parts seemed to drag but they were easily outweighed by the rest. I found the analysis of the Genesis creation account the most interesting - it appears to have been a deliberate attempt to subvert the Babylonian creation account as well as portions of some of their other myths. As such it may never have been intended to have been taken literally.
“The Rise and Fall of Adam and Eve” is an ambitious attempt at an important cultural history. It is cursory, and, to the degree that its treatment of these influential texts and movements is uninformed, it is not a help in understanding them. This thrilling work charts the slow process, from Augustine to Milton to Darwin, by which the Genesis story became no longer tenable As part of its unfathomable richness, the story of Adam and Eve reveals the nature of myth itself.
History.
Religion & Spirituality.
Nonfiction.
Stephen Greenblatt, autor de El giro, estudia en este libro la historia del relato bblico de la creacin de Adn y Eva, que ha marcado nuestras concepciones sobre el origen y destino de la especie humana. Nacido en Babilonia en la poca del exilio del pueblo judo, e influido por los mitos de viejas religiones, el cristianismo convirti el mito en un dogma y los artistas del Renacimiento lo encarnaron a semejanza de los hombres y mujeres de su tiempo. Este hilo conductor le sirve a Greenblatt para guiarnos en un fascinante recorrido por la historia de la cultura y de las creencias, desde el relato de la Vida de Adn y Eva descubierto en Nag Hammadi en 1945, pasando por San Agustn, por Milton o por las dudas de Darwin, hasta un presente en que, pese a los avances de la paleontologa y de la biologa evolutiva, millones de nuestros contemporneos siguen considerndolo una verdad histrica. No se han encontrado descripciones de biblioteca. |
Debates activosNingunoCubiertas populares
Google Books — Cargando... GénerosSistema Decimal Melvil (DDC)233.14Religions Christian doctrinal theology Theological anthropology; Humankind The fallClasificación de la Biblioteca del CongresoValoraciónPromedio:
¿Eres tú?Conviértete en un Autor de LibraryThing. |