I'm giving this 5 holy crap on a cracker stars. It probably was really a one or two star read in the real world. There was a whole heaping helping of WTF in this one. I can see where this story line could work and be pretty angsty but it was dealt with very oddly here. He knew from the time he was 20 and she was 5 that they weren't siblings but she didn't and fell in love with him anyway. It was explained off as her soul must have known. Or she could just be very mixed up and need some serious help. You decide. He should have told her years ago or even at anytime before the last 20 pages of this book. Oh well. Worth the read for vintage HP fans if you like the crazy. ( )