Pulse en una miniatura para ir a Google Books.
Cargando... The Hanging Tree (1994)por V. A. C. Gatrell
Ninguno Cargando...
Inscríbete en LibraryThing para averiguar si este libro te gustará. Actualmente no hay Conversaciones sobre este libro. In this learned and deeply impassioned work, Gatrell surveys the development of executions in England from the days of the “bloody code” in the late 18th and early 19th centuries—when people were executed for petty theft—through the legal reforms that made murder essentially the only crime punishable by death and finally to the abolition of execution as a public spectacle. He begins by considering what happens to the body during an execution. Even when things went “well,” many a person executed died in prolonged convulsions, the hangman pulling on the dying person’s legs to cause a final asphyxiation. If the drop was misjudged, the victim might be decapitated. If we are going to study this mode of punishment, Gatrell suggests, its realities had better be made clear. This book’s subjects, he reminds us, ‘once lived as we do’ . Using a variety of sources—not just trial records but ballads, broadsides, diaries and letters—Gatrell re-creates the lives and experiences of those who died, those who sentenced them to death, those who watched them die and those who mourned them. This is a work driven by outrage, a narrative alive with fury but one, also, of impeccable scholarship. ( ) While one's initial reaction to Gatrell's work may be emotional, positive, and, perhaps, disbelief, when one explores the historical foundations for his arguements, they turn out to be quite flawed. While Gatrell succeeds in attakting other historians for their oversimplification of Englicsh Penal Reform, he himself is guilty of this very same mistake in his book. What is more, the emotional overtones of his book undermine his attack on the emotional experience in history. What makes everyone else's emotional experience wrong and Gatrell's right? His book does make a strong contribution to the study of English Penal reform; it is too bad he limits himself by his contradiction. sin reseñas | añadir una reseña
Premios
Hanging people for small crimes as well as grave, the Bloody Penal Code was at its most active between 1770 and 1830. Some 7,000 men and women were executed on public scaffolds then, watched by crowds of thousands. Hanging was confined to murderers thereafter, but these were still killed in public until 1868. Clearly the gallows loomed over much of social life in this period. But how did those who watched, read about, or ordered these strangulations feel about the terror and suffering inflicted in the law's name? What kind of justice was delivered, and how did it change? This book is the first to explore what a wide range of people felt about these ceremonies (rather than what a few famous men thought and wrote about them). A history of mentalities, emotions, and attitudes rather than of policies and ideas, it analyses responses to the scaffold at all social levels: among the crowds which gathered to watch executions; among 'polite' commentators from Boswell and Byron on to Fry, Thackeray, and Dickens; and among the judges, home secretary, and monarch who decided who should hang and who should be reprieved. Drawing on letters, diaries, ballads, broadsides, and images, as well as on poignant appeals for mercy which historians until now have barely explored, the book surveys changing attitudes to death and suffering, 'sensibility' and 'sympathy', and demonstrates that the long retreat from public hanging owed less to the growth of a humane sensibility than to the development of new methods of punishment and law enforcement, and to polite classes' deepening squeamishness and fear of the scaffold crowd. This gripping study is essential reading for anyone interested in the processes which have 'civilized' our social life. Challenging many conventional understandings of the period, V.A.C. Gatrell sets new agendas for all students of eighteenth- and nineteenth-century culture and society, while reflecting uncompromisingly on the origins and limits of our modern attitudes to other people's misfortunes. Panoramic in range, scholarly in method, and compelling in argument, this is one of those rare histories which both shift our sense of the past and speak powerfully to the present. No se han encontrado descripciones de biblioteca. |
Debates activosNinguno
Google Books — Cargando... GénerosSistema Decimal Melvil (DDC)364.660941Social sciences Social problems and services; associations Criminology Punishment Death penaltyClasificación de la Biblioteca del CongresoValoraciónPromedio:
¿Eres tú?Conviértete en un Autor de LibraryThing. |