review of
John Brunner's Castaway's World / The Rites of Ohe
by tENTATIVELY, a cONVENIENCE - September 27, 2013

Being now an unabashed enthusiast for Brunner's writing, I take it for granted that even his most 'generic' SF will be rife w/ imaginative takes on whatever plot he unfurls. I have a 'soft spot' for Ace Doubles, I always respected their clever marketing, & 2 Brunner novels in one Double is good enuf for me. Despite that, tho, I have somewhat low expectations of a Double b/c I see them as a packaging of 2 novels that might not have enuf substance or length to stand on their own. That's not quite the case here b/c Brunner manages to make both stories rich enuf to be stand-alones.

Castaway's World, the 1st of the 2 I read, is sortof Brunner's Lord of the Flies told about people who've managed to make it to a livable, but not necessarily 'hospitable' world after fleeing the death of their planet of origin. Typical of Brunner, he adds some human touches that more 'hard-science' SF writers might avoid in their attn to imagining other more technical aspects of life on a new planet. There's sexual tension, eg:

""No!" Suddenly there was a shrill cry, and Naline was on her feet, clawing at Delvia's back. "No! You aren't going to go!"

[..]

"Tears coursing down her cheeks, voice rough-edged with hysteria, Naline shrieked, "Why don't you say why you want to go? Why don't you say it's to get away from me? Why don't you say it's so you can get Lex the way you've had every other man you could drag in the bushes?"" - pp 46-47

Of course, sexual tension is hardly a new theme in SF - take the somewhat standard trope of multiple men fighting over one surviving woman in an apocalypse scenario. Nonetheless, I think that Brunner deals w/ it in a somewhat more enlightened & realistic way (even tho the above quote doesn't fully reveal that). I reckon it's an equally standard trope to have a person crack up under such circumstances but, again, I think Brunner handles it better than many:

""They found the other party's ship, and that was what they were after. They didn't contact us by radio because they found it could be repaired. When they remembered that we'd go after them if there wasn't some reason why not, they staged this little drama with their guns to make us think they'd been eaten by animals or something. Now they'll take the other ship and get away!"

"The almost paranoid quality of the fantasy had shocked her listeners so that for a long moment open mouths and horrified expressions were her only response. Jerode was wondering at the back of his mind what provisions could be made here for insane persons, when he heard something shouted from outside which made him more relieved than he had imagined possible." - p 80

An example of the shades of William Golding's Lord of the Flies might be this: "Lex had read in the history of psychology about self-mutilation to gain sympathy and attention, but centuries of advancement in juvenile education had almost abolished such pathological behavior. if he hadn't seen what Gomes was doing, he would have found it hard to believe that regression could be so swift and far-reaching." (pp 81-82)

Anyway, I (gratefully) don't feel 'compelled' to say much about either of these 2 bks. I'm happy to see that the protagonist Lex is a "Polymath", altho a newly defined one, & I was thoroughly entertained.

The Rites of Ohe did it for me even more. Again, the basic plot isn't exactly new: humans & their contact w/ other humanoid civilizations - but Brunner has a nice central touch wch I won't give away here. There're "immortals", humans who've had their lifespans & abilities extended phenomenally. Immortal Karmesin is a thousand yrs old w/ thousands more ahead of him, the average lifespan for the average human being somewhere over 100. The bk's cast of characters is printed opposite the title page. Typical of these Ace Doubles, I find it a bit cheesy but I like it anyway:

Karmesin

He spoke with the voice of history from the vantage point of a thousand-year life span.


Merry Duner

With the destiny of planets at stake, she cared only for the man she loved.


Dombeno

A politician with a taste for power, he was jealous of Karmesin's supreme authority.


Snow

This courteous, golden-skinned alien gave his life in trying to hide the deadly secret of his people.


Remlong

Obviously, he was ashamed of not being an Ohean, and it had a dreadful effect on his objectivity.


Rex Quant

An idea he had—which he never took seriously—condemned him to a terrible fate.

Lurid, eh? Borderline TABLOID even.. &, of course, a bit misleading. I'm always interested in alternate dating systems (such as "E.V." (Era Vulgari)) & Brunner uses one here that I imagine might be used elsewhere: "By the twenty-third century CTE (Common Terrestrial Era)". (p 17) & then there's the touch that seems all-too-contemporary but, most likely, already existed by the time of the writing of this novel (in the form of Kamikaze pilots at least), the suicide bomber:

""Lawman Anse," he introduced himself briefly, "We seem to have found the bomber, Secretary."

""Where is he?" Dombeno tensed.

""Here," Anse informed him in a disgusted tone, and made the robot display its burden. On a slab of cracked artificial marble, torn from the interior wall of the old wing, there were several smears of blood and organic residues, and a heap of jagged debris interspersed with recognizable bits of bone." - p 41

Then there's stuff like an apparent reference to Wilhelm Reich's 1946 Listen, Little Man! as Immortal Karmesin puts Dombeno 'in his place' by calling him a "Little man" twice during a conference (p 45) & then says it more explicitly again: "["] Listen, little man, I don't care about disrupting your city, or your planet for that matter.["]" (p 50)

My own experiences w/ family being considerably less than satisfactory, I read this part w/ especial interest: "She had sometimes wondered what life was like for people in the old days, the periods Rex studied, for example, or, more immediately, the days Karmesin could remember, when there were still traces of primitive human social structure such as the semi-permanent family. Modern human education was largely directed toward early self-sufficiency, in recognition of the race's apparent inability to impose on itself close-quarter ties lasting more than about two decades." (p 75) GURRRLLL you ain't missing much - at least from my perspective.

&, HEY!, I just realized that neither of these stories had hypnosis or steam cars, like so many other Brunner bks I've read do. There IS an instantaneously induced suicide that I vaguely remember encountering elsewhere.. but I cdn't find it in any of the other Brunner bks I've read so maybe it was in someone else's bk.

"The two gold-skinned men looked at one another. Snow gave a kind of non-human shrug, and Wanhope said something. As one, they closed their eyes and folded toward the floor like dolls.

""What the—?" exclaimed Kraesser, glancing up. the lawmen made to dive forward.

""Hold it!" Karmesin rapped, and switched on the speaker in his pocket again. The artificial voice spoke after a moment.

""First speaker: expression indicative of futility and discontinuance of effort, overtones of hopelessly disturbed pattern in the sense of pattern of events. Concept of permanent voluntary cessation, or death for two persons inclusive of speaker."

""As though we didn't know," Karmesin said, and switched it off." - p 86

What happens when 2 societies meet? One capable of interstellar travel, the other planetbound for a much longer time than the star-travelers have been around? Read this story, & other exciting tales from John Brunner, & find out!! ( )