The first Bookman piece in the series was intriguing enough that I decided to read the second. I could barely make it through the first third. I kept forcing myself to read it, because I'd bought, but finally I found the writing so poor that I couldn't do it anymore. ( )

Meet Lady De Winter, agent to France’s quiet council of intelligent automatons who is called to a locked room mystery and as is the way of things is soon involved in a grasp for a bizarre zombie creating alien artefact which will drive her to underground labs, terrifying asylums, beautiful world fairs fighting against the British giant space lizards and a multitude of Chinese factions.

Utterly fabulous, totally silly and quite, quite serious; this a mad cap, magpie of an adventure story. It’s very hard to encapsulate every delight here, it’s an over-packed gem but a hugely satisfying one. An adventure romp with a meaty almost meandering plot that is packed to the rafters with literature references and neat ideas. The characters are superb (look women in fantasy!) De Winter is a perfect example of anti-authority cop and all the minor
characters seem to be spot on whether it’s the repulsive Marquis De Sade, or tragic Kai Lun.

All genres are pretty much mashed here but never overwhelm and the plot is a page turner but maybe not for those who prefer threads tight and few and tied up at the end. It is the 2nd in the Bookman trilogy but is pretty much standalone and um I can't think of many faults to be honest. I did have a niggling need to know more about French literature but it didn't affect the story just my pride and I had much fun with Google.

Recommended for all horror, crime, sci fi, fantasy and adventure fans. Plus everyone else ( )

I really loved The Bookman, the first in Tidhar's trilogy, and there were parts of Camera Obscura that I really loved too - especially when she encounters Holmes's murder castle outside the White City. However, the fourth part disgusted me so much that it slowed my reading of it to almost a complete stop; I had to take it in very small doses, and this diminished my liking of it. ( )

I got an e-galley of this book through NetGalley.com. I was drawn to the interesting description and the mysterious title of the book. This was an absolutely fantastic book, but definitely not something everyone will enjoy. Those who like quirky characters and worlds that are gritty and a bit ambiguous will find a lot here to love. Those who like their stories happy with well-defined storylines should probably look elsewhere. I didn't know it when I picked this up but this is the second book in this series: the first is The Bookman. This book seemed to provide a good stand alone story; but I am sure I missed some background by not reading the first novel in the series.

The Lady DeWinter works for the Quiet Council as an investigator. Her current assignment is to find the whereabouts of a jade statue for them. But then people start turning up dead and DeWinter is being hunted by shadows. There are a lot of factions in town looking for this jade statue and none of them are afraid to kill for it. When the Phantom (a fellow agent gone serial killer) starts on the trail he may be the biggest and deadliest thing standing between DeWinter and her goal. This book is set in a Victorian like France, where a lizard-like people rule Great Britain, and automatons roam the streets. There are small sections of the book that are told from a boy named Kai's point of view; he is the one who originally has the jade statue.

The book moves quickly and is incredibly engaging; it was very hard to put this book down and I found myself staying up way too late reading it. Tidhar does an excellent job with description; making the surroundings and characters easy to picture. The world built is incredibly interesting. You have Great Britain occupied by a race of lizard people and complex politics woven around all of that. The action scenes are plentiful and exceedingly well done.

The characters are all quirky, unique and very interesting. That being said there isn't a lot of emotion in this book; DeWinter never really has a love interest and that is just not what this book is about. This book is more about the investigation going on and finding deeper hidden truths beneath all of the layers of deceit that DeWinter comes up against. It is also about creating a unqiue and intriguing world. People who are very into emotionally driven stories may not enjoy this book as much.

The setting throughout the novel is very dark and gritty. DeWinters is constantly scrapping through the underworld and in a state of almost being completely run down. Again this dark style may be a turn off to some. The plot is very complex involving multiple factions and layers of intrigue and I really enjoyed it. The book ends well and wraps things up nicely.

In general this is a strange book, but midway through it gets even stranger. This is the only part of the book that gave me pause. Midway through our heroine goes through massive destruction; I am not sure why this had to happen. I do believe DeWinter came out the other side of it all more interesting, but the emotional damage she would have gained from that trauma wasn't represented all that well (as I said not an emotional book). Things get even stranger toward the end and start involving alien space travel and gates to other realities. I really like weird books; but towards the end this book bending towards the too weird region of weird for me. It was getting to the point where the story was a bit contrived and outlandish...luckily it never got to that point for me but it was close. Some readers may not enjoy the absolutely strange twists and turns; but if nothing else the book will keep you guessing.

Overall I really, really enjoyed this book. The completely unique world and the crazy twisting plot really pulled me in. The characters are interesting and unique (if never really emotionally involved) and the mystery and action absolutely spot on. The dark tone to the book and the strangeness of it all towards the end of the book may be a turn-off for some readers. If you like dark stories, with a little amibiguity, and a lot of strange this is definitely the book for you. It was very well done and very well thought out. I will definitely be picking up more books by Tidhar in the future. ( )