Jack Finegan (1908–2000)

Book can have multiple personality disorder just as much as people.

I'm honestly not sure if this book wants to be primarily about textual criticism (that is, determining the original text of the New Testament), or about paleography (that is, the study of ancient writing and what it tells us about manuscripts), or about the evolution of text-types within the New Testament tradition.

There are major sections on each of these topics. The first quarter of the book is mostly about how ancient manuscripts were made -- paleography. The next quarter is about textual criticism. Then we start seeing actual manuscript photos -- but they're organized into "sequences" illustrating the (alleged) history of text-types. Then we get "conclusions" and "the future task" to try to bind it all together.

The best part of the book is probably the manuscript photos. It would be nicer if they were in color, but the book is from the 1970s.... There is useful analysis of each manuscript page shown, with a transcription into modern Greek lettering and information about abbreviations and such. This will be a genuine help to the beginner trying to learn Greek handwriting (especially minuscule handwriting, which is the hardest to read). But to really learn this topic requires more samples. And the other sections are even less complete.

Plus the author is really, really wordy. Many of his sentences are longer than a better writer's paragraphs.

On the whole, I would have to consider this more a first taste than a genuine introduction. It's good to have all those samples and analysis, but you'll need far, far more to learn to be either a paleographer or a textual critic.… (más)