Sarah Fay
Autor de Pathological: The True Story of Six Misdiagnoses
Obras de Sarah Fay
Obras relacionadas
Etiquetado
Conocimiento común
- Fecha de nacimiento
- 20th Century
- Género
- female
- Nacionalidad
- USA
- Lugares de residencia
- Chicago, Illinois, USA
Miembros
Reseñas
Listas
También Puede Gustarte
Autores relacionados
Estadísticas
- Obras
- 1
- También por
- 1
- Miembros
- 29
- Popularidad
- #460,290
- Valoración
- 3.8
- Reseñas
- 2
- ISBNs
- 7
- Idiomas
- 1
I mean, I can't disagree with the author's experience. Mental illness is such a weird thing, where so many people "have it," but nobody can say what causes it and what fixes it, and how to really diagnose and categorize in an objective way. I am not unsympathetic to the anti-psychiatry crowd. But I wonder... what was the author's point in writing this book? Anger at what she went through? Something else? This book does contain lots of citations about other people's work, but I do not find this book to be a particularly compelling exposure of the weakness of psychiatry, which has been detailed in many other texts. While relatable at times, I did not find the author's life narrative to be compelling enough to justify a full-length book either.
Yet, to top it off, the author concludes at the end of the book that the rationale for her illness(es?) can be explained by: evolutionary psychology. I mean, if you wanted to take a current trend that had the absolute minimum basis in actual empirical fact, and is based on the rationalizations and assumptions made by (mostly) male and (mostly) white academics, evopsych would be that trend. It is not scientific, it is not empirical, and it is not feminist either. (Cave women make babies while cave men hunt. Duh.) So how does the author square her distrust of the DSM (for science reasons!) and not realize that evopsych is not in the least bit scientific.
Weaved in throughout the narrative is a history and some information about different types of punctuation. I guess in case you forgot the author is a writer and teaches English. I wasn't sure what these digressions added to the memoir.… (más)