Deborah Fallows

The authors recount their frequent small-plane flights to various small and mid-size cities across the Lower 48 (most of the places they visit can't really fairly be called towns). In each section they highlight the unique aspects of each place and how the area was coping with various pressures in the mid-2010s, finding common themes that tend to unite the success stories. They tend to downplay discord and systemic problems, and often their tales come off as a bit more optimistic and boostery than perhaps is warranted. (I am, to be fair, perhaps more jaded than the ideal reader for this book).

I'd be curious to read about some of the places they mention in passing that didn't seem to be doing as well, for example. But there is a lot of interesting content here, anyway, and the book gives a good sense of how some cities are finding imaginative ways to thrive.… (más)

Just sad that this book hasn't lived up to my expectations. But it does have some redeeming factors.

First the bad: I agree with other reviewers that it is pretentious and elitist writing from an east-coast standpoint. The authors shouldn't be so surprised to discover things like libraries in these places, or so quick to apply their own definitions to terms that obviously mean different things to different people. For a journalist and a linguist, they really don't write very well....or maybe they just needed a good editor. It was annoying for them to discuss a problem for several paragraphs, then never tell us what the local solution was. I also wonder if maybe organizing the book by "solutions" and making it shorter rather than by "city/trip" would have made it more readable. Finally, these are not "towns." With an average population of over 146,000, the places the Fallows visit are clearly cities. And they really don't focus on much more than economic problems and city revitalization.

The good: city or town planners will probably find some good ideas here that they might be able to apply to their situations. If you are concerned about revitalizing your community or trying to solve some local economic problems, you might find some good suggestions here, but pick one chapter and their final suggestions and skip the rest of the book.… (más)