J. Burke

Originally published in Australia, this short and very simple chapter book has been reprinted by the American publisher Stone Arch Books, which specializes in "Hi-Lo" books. These are books that are aimed at older students who are reading well below their appropriate age and grade level - "high interest, low level."

It took less than twenty minutes to actually read this title, which follows the story of young Caroline, who becomes convinced that an evil doll is making her mother ill. The suspense, elements of horror, and thirteen-year-old protagonist, all make this a good book for reluctant older readers.

But although I have been a reading tutor, at various points, and have an interest in "Hi-Lo" books, my primary motivation in picking up The Deadly Doll was to look at Shaun Tan's illustrations. These are mostly black & white etchings, very different in style from the intricate and colorful paintings to be found in The Red Tree or The Rabbits, and I had mixed feelings about them. Some seemed a little crude to me, given the delicacy required for this style; others left me indifferent; and one or two seemed truly inspired. The best of the lot was the picture of Caroline and her father at the kitchen table, which somehow managed to communicate a sense of both intimacy and eerieness.

Interest Level: Grades 5-9, Ages 10-14
Reading Level: Grades 2-3… (más)

I picked this little book up at the library since I'm trying to get my hands on every book that Shaun Tan, of The Arrival and The Lost Thing fame, has collaborated on. This one featured lovely little etchings by the artist, which were the perfect accompaniment to what I thought was a terrifying story: a package containing a large antique doll which has been in the family for over a hundred years arrives in the mail from France one day; our young heroine used to collect dolls, but at thirteen, she's much too old for them, so she plonks the unwelcome toy down on a chair and promptly forgets about it; but the doll has a will of her own, and won't be ignored.

I've always been really spooked by old china dolls, and this story expresses exactly the kind of horror that those unseeing shiny glass eyes have always inspired in me. Really scary. But as it's a children's/YA book, it has a happy ending of course. Or does it?… (más)