Sobre El Autor
Obras de Brian Boeck
Etiquetado
Conocimiento común
- Fecha de nacimiento
- 1971-08-08
- Género
- male
- Nacionalidad
- USA
- Educación
- Harvard University
- Ocupaciones
- assistant professor of history
- Organizaciones
- DePaul University
Miembros
Reseñas
Premios
Estadísticas
- Obras
- 2
- Miembros
- 45
- Popularidad
- #340,917
- Valoración
- 4.0
- Reseñas
- 1
- ISBNs
- 11
Boeck returns multiple times to the accusations of plagiarism made against Sholokhov throughout his life, including accusations made by Solzhynitzyn. He grants Sholokhov a pass for parts of Quiet Don which the author may have taken from anonymous sources. It was Sholokhov’s skill as a writer that molded any lifted sections of other works into a literary narrative, Boeck tells us.
One problem I had with an otherwise good recommendation was Brian J. Boeck’s description of collectivization, 1932-24, which included Ukraine as well as the Don region. Boeck’s description of collectivization reads like a detached technical manual. Primo Levi was able to describe his year at Auschwitz with the detachment of the chemist because he was a prisoner there! In Levi’s hand, such a detached style intensified the horror. Boeck cannot be given the same dispensation, not when one of the greatest genocides by a leader against his own people was being perpetrated. Boeck's detached style in this section of the book calls attention to the author, pushing us outside the narrative -- something no author wants to invite.
Boeck, a scholar, has indexed his book thoroughly -- his footnotes number 41 pages. It takes some skill to bring such a well-researched book to the public free of the caveat that it can be a slog. Boeck's book is hardly that. Note: the library book in my possession spells the author's name, Boeck, not h. Correction of above.… (más)