Fotografía de autor

Sobre El Autor

Obras de Amy J. L. Baker

Etiquetado

Conocimiento común

Género
female

Miembros

Reseñas

This is, without a doubt, the worst divorce book I've ever read.

It may be the worst divorce book ever written. I haven't read all of them, so I can't say for sure, but I do feel confident enough in that opinion that if a contest were open tomorrow asking for nominations in the category of Worst Divorce Book in History, I would without hesitation suggest this book.

None of you are curious as to my reasoning, but in classic Andrea fashion, I'm going to tell you anyway.

The ex-partner is, in every instance throughout the entire book, referred to as "her."

And what is this mysterious "her" doing?

Making false allegations of abuse.

What about if the ex ("her" or otherwise) is doing some abusing and the reader is curious as to how to handle the high-conflict fall-out of having to make those allegations?

Nope. Not a word. Only "false" allegations are covered.

What if the ex (again, "her" or otherwise) is just an enormously difficult person who likes blowing off steam by starting fights all the time over nothing? What if you are looking for advice in how to handle this situation when it doesn't involve lawyers and judges?

Not a mention.

So the whole book is really about ex-wives who are trying to "get back" at ex-husbands through false allegations of abuse, eh?

Yes. The whole thing.

Well, but is that such a bad thing? It happens, right? These guys need a book too.

Sure! And if it seemed actually targeted to innocent people who were unfairly accused of things they didn't do as part of a custody battle, it wouldn't be at all helpful to me personally, but I would have no beef with it.

Though it's worth pointing out that I know quite a few people at this point in my life who tell a terrible tale of woe about the horrible ex and all the untrue accusations she made, just to be retaliatory; and I've got to say that all but one of them are completely full of it. I mean there is only one such person I might think of as being potentially innocent, and the rest were so generally awful to people and did such terrible things that--no matter what the courts said--I believe their ex-wives.

Still. Let's disregard that.

Consider this quote, starting p. 171:

To begin with, we suggest that you refrain from corporal punishment of any kind (spanking, pinching, hitting, slapping) ... in order to eliminate the possibility that you could inflict injury resulting in a physical abuse claim being filed against you. Also avoid grabbing your child or restraining your child physically, unless it is absolutely necessary in response to a safety concern. Any time that you are feeling angry at your child, make sure to avoid physical contact. ... Stay calm and in control of your emotions. If your child hits you or provokes you physically, you should withdraw a few steps and deal with the matter verbally.

To protect yourself from allegations of sexual abuse, refrain from being naked in front of your children, sleeping under the covers with them (or even lying on the bed with them, unless you are fully clothed), bathing with them, washing their private parts, kissing them on the mouth, allowing or enabling them to watch R-rated movies, or having any kind of pornography in the house. ... You also might want to be very mindful about any kind of sexual teasing, horseplay, wrestling, and suggestive language...."


It goes on in this way.

Isn't this what good parents already do?

Umm, yes. Yes, I believe it is. Yes, I believe good, non-abusive parents probably don't need to be told not to slap their children, not to be naked in front of them, and not to make lewd comments to them. These actions aren't "things that could be mistaken for abuse." They ARE ABUSE.

This--and other passages much like it--leaves one with the impression that it isn't so much a handbook to allow innocent men to defend themselves successfully in family court, but to allow abusive men to get away with it. And it makes me feel physically ill.
… (más)
 
Denunciada
andrea_mcd | Mar 10, 2020 |

Estadísticas

Obras
13
Miembros
118
Popularidad
#167,490
Valoración
½ 3.4
Reseñas
1
ISBNs
33

Tablas y Gráficos