Hmm. Wasn't really thrilled with this book. I found it to be a bit dry and boring. Hamilton has a way of cramming so much plot into each story. Consequently, something is lost in translation... ( )

My interest in classical mythology dates from the time when I, 15 years old, first read Edith Hamilton's book, "Mythology." I shall forever be grateful to Ms. Hamilton for her wonderful introduction to a subject that, for me, never begins to pale. ( )

Short review for this one.

I love mythology. I’d just like to start off by saying that. The Edith Hamilton edition was part of my assigned summer reading. I’d already read a great deal of the legends so I was looking forward to expanding my knowledge with what was hailed as the ultimate mythology source.

But this was just…a disappointment. Or pick any other adjective you like: dry, tedious, bland—they’re all applicable. Edith Hamilton does know her stuff, I won’t deny that. I did learn quite a few things, which is excellent, but throughout the reading I couldn’t help but feel that I would have had a more riveting time if I had just looked up the stories on Wikipedia.

I know that this book is essentially a reference book, and reference books aren’t traditional leisure reading for most. But mythological stories should never be yawn-inducing. I went into the book expecting to be excited by the adventures of the gods and heroes and instead, I couldn’t wait for it to be over.

And though I don’t doubt that Hamilton knows her stuff, I found that a few of the stories didn’t add up with my previous knowledge. For example, I had learned that the Gorgons were three beautiful sisters and that Medusa was cursed after she was caught having sex with Poseidon in Athena’s tower. (A much more exciting version of events, in my humble opinion.) Also, discussing Hephaestus, she briefly mentions that in some legends he was thrown off the side of Olympus after his birth—well, that was the way I learned it, and it was an interesting story. Aside from that, gods like Hephaestus (and Ares) are barely discussed at all.

The one entertaining thing was counting how many times people turned into trees or flowers.

If you’re looking for a book on mythology, the Edith Hamilton edition is informative but not very interesting. If I had an alternative recommendation I would name it, but I’m still searching, unfortunately. ( )

A classic used in classrooms. I use a variety of books teaching mythology, but I refer back to Edith fairly often. Very accessible for high school students.

Un travail essentiel, très bien agencé et complet. L'auteur raconte les grands (et moins grands) mythes antiques avec beaucoup d'élégance. Parfois les récits souffrent de la concision, mais il s'agit d'un ouvrage d'introduction plus que d'une somme définitive. Très précieux, certains mythes sont réellement enchanteurs par leur finesse, leur imagination et leur poésie. ( )