The historical detail in this book is pretty well done. It’s on a historical subject (Crimean War) that is not really covered by a lot of YA out on shelves. So, to choose a subject like Florence Nightingale, the Crimean War,and nursing is an interesting one. So right then the plot was bound to be interesting for any historical YA reader out there.

I myself was a little disappointed. Although I like the historical detail, the book is really just a love story. It did focus a lot on the romance elements and less on Molly and her nursing job which was unfortunate. I don’t have much knowledge about this particular aspect on history and a little more information would have been better than just reading the romance story, nevertheless the romance was all right and readable, but to some historical fiction fanatics this might not be something they want to delve into.

I for one, could not really sympathize with Emma, and I actually figured out just by being introduced to her character what was going to happen to her. It just seems to be common that there’s going to be that one stupid character to cause a great upheaval (whether good or bad) in the main character’s storyline. Argh. Someone surprise me with a scenario where the main character slaps the stupid one upside the head and leaves her to her own fate. I’d love to read something like that. What’s even more aggravating? Will just happened to be a character to be conveniently there. Oh goodness. Can I roll my eyes now?

This wasn’t really what I was looking for. I was hoping more historical fiction. Less romance. Not really recommended unless romance is more your style. ( )

I liked the historical part of the novel featuring Florence Nightingale, but it was spoiled by a contrived romantic triangle. ( )

I am embarrassingly under-informed about the Crimean War . Basically, all I knew about it before reading this book that it was the scene of Florence Nightingale’s nursing innovations and that the Charge of the Light Brigade happened during the conflict. (oh, and I knew the British and the Russians were fighting but I had no clue who else) During the war, Nightingale pioneered many modern nursing practices after seeing the awful living conditions to which wounded and sick soldiers were subjected. In the Shadow of the Lamp follows a young girl from a life in service to Turkey as a part of Nightingale’s nursing corps. I don’t often comment on the actual titles of books but this one is absolutely perfect. We read about famous figures in our history textbooks, but wherever those people were, there were loads of people we never hear anything about. Nightingale was known as “The Lady of the Lamp” because she would walk through the wards checking on patients during the night hours with an oil lamp. There were thousands of people in and out of those wards, patients, nurses, doctors, nuns, and this could be one of their stories.

The opening scene sees Molly Fraser, a 17 year old London girl, fired from her job as a parlormaid after a fellow employee fabricates a story of Molly thieving from their employers. With limited options, Molly decides to attempt to join Nightingale’s nurses on their voyage to the Crimea. Her only problems? She isn’t a nurse, has near no money, and has no references. It’s no spoiler that she finagles her way there.

My enjoyment of the book was hindered by the characterization of Molly. If this were an adult novel, I would be calling her a tease and naïve and her choices frustrating. However, this isn’t written for adults, relationships and courtship were quite different in the 19th century, and the protagonist is only 17. She was, however, consistent in her oft-ridiculous decisions. For example, say you were a young woman with no nursing training and Florence Nightingale told you point blank that if you fraternized with anyone, you’d be sent back to England. What would you do? Yeah, me too. She is, however, a loyal friend, a caring nurse, and a hard worker, all of which I appreciated. Molly doesn’t want to be a tease or to make these decisions, either. Just writing this paragraph has brought me to terms with her. She carries the story well and I wanted to see where Dunlap would take Molly all the way to the end.

I must admit that I was far more interested in the history and nursing aspects of the novel rather than the romance. For the first hundred or so pages, I plowed through Molly’s travel experience and smiled with enthusiasm as Nightingale and her nurses cleaned the vermin-filled, rotten, sewage-smelling, unhygienic wards until they were livable. Then again, I am a huge sucker for cleaning-up montages and before and after pictures. (even if they are only mental images) The second half of the novel concentrates more on the love triangle aspect of Molly's journey--if YA love triangles are driving you up the wall, you'd best give this a pass. I was rather apathetic about which person Molly ended up with or whose advances she accepted but the unique setting and Dunlap's writing kept me invested in the story.

The story never feels too weighed down and the pacing is consistent throughout. The author's descriptions of all the gory details of battle injuries, missing limbs, and the overall grossness of the situation in terms of sanitation were strong without feeling overdone. Historical fiction is not usually my bag but I would/will definitely read other books by this author. I dig her style, I only wish I enjoyed the characters a bit more than I did.

3.5 stars. ( )

Molly is dismissed from her parlor maid position after another employee sets her up. Wandering the streets of London, Molly hears that Florence Nightingale is looking for nurses to travel into war to help British soldiers. After being turned down for the position, Molly smuggles herself onto their boat. Surprised by her determination, Florence decides to take her on.

This was a very interesting book. I found myself reading far into the night. It is well written, the characters are engaging and the plot is well paced. I look forward to reading the authors other books. ( )

Reviewed by Jennifer Rummel for TeensReadToo.com

Molly's been unfairly dismissed from her maid's position. She has nowhere to go, until she hears about a nursing opportunity. She doesn't have much experience, though, and thus she's rejected from the girls and women picked for Miss Nightingale's staff.

But Molly's determined to make it and sneaks onto the ship with the rest of the group. Most of the women aboard become sea sick due to the rough waters. Molly and another girl help any way they can and attempt to clean up the messes. Due to this, upon arrival, Molly's allowed to join the nursing staff.

She soon learns that Miss Nightingale keeps strict rules. Anyone caught breaking those rules will be sent home.

Molly tends to the soldiers as best she can - helping to wrap bandages, assisting the doctors, wiping the brows of the injured, and talking to them in an attempt to keep them calm. Although the work is tough and the conditions even harder, she knows that she's making a difference.

However, Molly doesn't always follow the rules. Lately, it's getting harder and harder to remain angelic. Will her actions cost her this amazing position?

I found the politics of the hospital and the battle for improving the conditions of the wounded fascinating. I loved the in-depth look at both nursing and Miss Nightingale's character. This subject is not found often in YA literature, and it is a great tool for learning more about the time period. IN THE SHADOW OF THE LAMP is a wonderful look at the Crimean War - filled with the horrors of fighting, friendships among the nurses, and even the possibility of romance. ( )